Dear Constituent,
Thank you for writing to me on the Bill of Rights Bill.
The Ministry of Justice has explained that the Bill:
- Strengthens the right to freedom of speech. We are attaching greater weight to freedom of speech, defined as the exchange of ideas, opinions, information and facts, as a matter of utmost public interest, and widening the responsibility for attaching this greater weight to all public authorities.
- Recognises the right to jury trial. The Bill recognises the right to trial by jury under, and subject to, the framework set by Parliament and the Scottish and Northern Ireland legislatures.
- Limits courts’ powers for certain rights. Human rights, especially Article 8 (right to family life), have been used to frustrate the deportation of criminals. The Bill will apply when a court considers deportation laws, especially those that may seek in the future to make it more difficult for foreign criminals to use Article 8 to appeal their deportation. It will set out that the legislation must be found compatible with those rights if it meets a new test which the Bill of Rights sets out. This will restore credibility to the system and ensure we can protect the public by deporting those who pose a serious threat.
- Reduces burdens on public authorities. We are limiting the imposition of positive obligations on our public services without proper democratic oversight. We are making clear that when public authorities are giving clear effect to primary legislation, they are not acting unlawfully. We are doing this by restricting UK courts’ power to interpret legislation. This will deliver greater certainty for public services to do the jobs entrusted to them, without the constant threat of having to defend against expensive human rights claims.
- Ensures that public protection is given due regard in interpretation of rights. The Bill contains a provision that obliges all those who interpret Convention rights to consider the need to reduce the risk to the public from convicted criminals serving a custodial sentence. This supports the Government’s proposed reforms to the Parole Board and strengthens the Government’s hand in fighting Article 8 claims from terrorists opposing their placement in Separation Centres.
- Limits the Bill’s territorial jurisdiction. Domestic and Strasbourg case law has extended beyond the intent of the Convention’s drafters. The Bill excludes extraterritorial jurisdiction for military operations abroad.
- Implements a permission stage to ensure trivial cases do not undermine public confidence in human rights. The introduction of a permission stage will ensure that courts focus on serious human rights claims and places responsibility on the claimant to demonstrate that they have suffered a significant disadvantage before a human rights claim can be heard in court.
- Recognises that responsibilities exist alongside rights. We are recognising that responsibilities exist alongside rights and ensuring that the appropriateness of paying damages to those who have infringed the rights of others is considered.
- Strengthens domestic institutions and the primacy of UK law. The Bill empowers UK courts to apply human rights in a UK context, affirming the Supreme Court’s independence from the Strasbourg Court. The Bill makes explicit that the UK Supreme Court is the ultimate judicial arbiter.
- Increases democratic oversight. The Bill makes sure that the balance between our domestic institutions is right, by repealing section 3 of the Human Rights Act 1998 to ensure that UK courts can no longer alter legislation contrary to its ordinary meaning and the overall purpose of the law.
- Enhances Parliament’s role in responding to adverse Strasbourg rulings. The Bill enhances the role of Parliament in responding to adverse Strasbourg judgments against the UK. The Bill also affirms Parliament’s supremacy in the making of laws.
Thank you again.
Yours sincerely,
Mel Stride MP
MP for Central Devon